Menu
Simple Goodness Sisters
0
  • Shop
    • Join the Cocktail Farm Club
    • Drink Syrups
    • Drink Your Garden Cocktail Book
    • Books + Recipe Cards
    • Drink Ingredients
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Products
    • The Sisters
    • The Cocktail Farm
    • Our Partners
    • Press
    • Blog
  • Recipes
  • The Soda Shop
  • Events
  • Sign in
  • Your Cart is Empty
Simple Goodness Sisters
  • Shop
    • Join the Cocktail Farm Club
    • Drink Syrups
    • Drink Your Garden Cocktail Book
    • Books + Recipe Cards
    • Drink Ingredients
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Our Products
    • The Sisters
    • The Cocktail Farm
    • Our Partners
    • Press
    • Blog
  • Recipes
  • The Soda Shop
  • Events
  • 0 0

Simple Goodness Hot Toddy

November 16, 2021

The Hot Toddy is a classic cocktail in the cozy hall of fame for a reason, and now we've reinvented it from garden to glass.

The formula for a hot toddy cocktail is pretty simple, and when made simply, they're good. They're a staple in Fall and Winter, when head colds and frigid temperatures make you crave a warm drink. The base of lemon, hot water, sugar or honey, and whiskey is a great soother of throats and cabin fever. Our Grandma Nancy is well known for sugegsting one before a cough drop. A good old holiday movie and a Hot Toddy just can't be beat, says Nanc the wellness guru.

Make them with Simple Goodness Sisters syrups in delightfully true to the season flavors like Rhubarb Vanilla Bean, Apple Pie, or Lemon Herb, and this warm drink gets a modern upgrade that helps keep it fresh and exciting yearround.

I love to switch around the syrups for whichever season I find myself in. I use Apple Pie syrup in Fall, when warm spiced like cinnamon are all I'm craving after the heat of summer, and Rhubarb Vanilla when the hot house rhubarb starts growing in the valley near our farm. Lemon Herb syrup in a toddy gets me excited for Winter citrus season, when the stores fill with oranges and lemons from California and I play with the subtle differences of adding meyer lemons (a sweeter version of a lemon) or blood oranges to the drink. In sum, hot toddies are not just your grandma's sick day recommendation any longer. They're toasty, soothing, perfectly balanced blank canvases, waiting for you to add in your syrup of choice.



The Simple Goodness Hot Toddy

Glass: ceramic or heat safe glass mug

Ingredients:

  • 4 ounces warm water
  • 1 ½ ounces bourbon
  • ¾ ounce Simple Goodness Sisters syrup
  • 1 tea bag (optional)
  • 1 slice of lemon or other citrus
  • Cinnamon stick

A note on interesting combinations to try:

  • Rhubarb Vanilla + black tea + lemon
  • Lemon Herb + Meyer Lemon (no tea)
  • Apple Pie + Lemon + ginger tea
  • Berry Sage + Orange + chamomile tea

How to Make it:

Heat water to very warm but not boiling in a sauce pot or kettle. You can simply measure and add all ingredients to a wide mouth mug.

Or, make the drink like the pros: pour the hot water into the larger tin of a set of cocktail shaking tins. Add the tea bag, if using, to infuse in the hot water. Now nestle and float the smaller tin in the hot water. Use this small tin to begin mixing the drink. First measure in the bourbon to warm it slowly, raising the temperature without muting flavors or diluting it. Add Rhubarb Vanilla syrup and a lemon slice to the warming bourbon. Remove the floating tin from the tea water. Pour the hot tea water into the bourbon mix, then pour it all in a wide mouth mug. The wider the top of the mug, the less you will smell the warm alcohol vapors as you drink. After infusing for 3-5 minutes, remove the tea bag and add a cinnamon stick.


Nonalcoholic: To make it a mocktail, simply omit the spirit for a cozy, hot drink with many possible flavor combinations.

Like this recipe? Please share it. Tag us when you make your drinks on social, we'd love to send you a "cheers!"

  • Share:


Also in Simple Goodness Sisters Recipes

DIY Lemonade Bar: A Mix-and-Match Garden Party Showstopper
DIY Lemonade Bar: A Mix-and-Match Garden Party Showstopper

March 24, 2026

Create a beautiful, interactive DIY lemonade bar that turns any garden party or shower into a memorable experience. This mix-and-match setup pairs fresh lemonade with handcrafted or Simple Goodness Syrups, vibrant garnishes, and simple styling tips for a Pinterest-worthy drink station your guests will love.

Read More

Fresh Lemonade, the Simple Goodness Way (with Real Fruit Syrups)
Fresh Lemonade, the Simple Goodness Way (with Real Fruit Syrups)

March 24, 2026

Bright, fresh, and endlessly customizable—this Simple Goodness lemonade recipe blends real lemon juice with handcrafted fruit syrups for a naturally delicious twist on a classic. Perfect for batching, bottling, and enjoying.

Read More

Batched Holiday Craft Cocktails for Parties: This is Not Your Grandma's Punch
Batched Holiday Craft Cocktails for Parties: This is Not Your Grandma's Punch

December 05, 2025

These punch recipes I will share are not your gram's punch, nostalgic as it is, these are craft cocktail recipes that are adjusted to serve a crowd and smartly contain ingredients that work well when sitting with ice over a few hours during a party, and even sitting batched in the fridge hours before, so that you can prep food and light candles instead of worrying about the drinks.

Read More

Follow
  • Search
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscription Policy
  • Affiliates
  • Terms of Service
  • Join our Newsletter

Sign up or our newsletter below to keep in touch with our community

© 2026 Simple Goodness Sisters.
Powered by Shopify

American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Mastercard Shop Pay Visa